Second-chance offers
Nov 22, 2026
We recommend that, at launch, your team sends each second-chance offer from a queue in the admin, with a suggested next step for every unpaid lot. Once a few sales show a pattern, the offers within a gap you set can go out automatically.
The decision
Agreed on 20 Nov: an overdue invoice stops the buyer’s bidding; the underbidder is offered the lot at their own bid; below the reserve, a 24-hour offer at the reserve, then back to the archive; the non-payer pays the difference. Open: who sends the offer, and when a lot goes back instead.
- A · Your team sends each offer from a queue, with a suggested next step (recommended).
- B · Automatic as soon as the invoice is overdue.
- C · Automatic within a gap you set; your team decides the rest.
What you told us
- The offer goes to the underbidder “at their price” (20 Nov).
- Close to the reserve, offer it; far off, put it back (20 Nov).
- At “30, 40% lower” it’s better to rerun the sale (18 Nov).
- Don’t stack edge cases (20 Nov).
How other houses do it
| House | Who decides the second chance |
|---|---|
| Heritage | May sell to “any underbidders”; the defaulter pays the shortfall and commission |
| eBay | The seller picks which bidders get an offer, at their own last bid, up to 60 days after |
| Propstore | Resells as it sees fit; may refuse the defaulter’s future bids |
| RR Auction | Resells; the defaulter pays the deficiency and damages |
None of the houses we checked publishes an automatic rule; a person decides.
Options compared
| A · Queue (recommended) | B · Automatic | C · Automatic within a gap | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offer goes out | Same day, when your team clicks | At once | At once inside the gap |
| A bid far below the winner | Your team relists | Offered anyway | Your team decides |
| Team effort | One click per unpaid lot | None | Only for wide gaps |
| Best when | Few unpaid lots, rules still settling | Rules proven | After a few sales |
Our recommendation and why
Option A at launch. Unpaid lots should be few, every one is a judgement call while the rules are new, and the queue keeps that call quick: the admin shows the winning bid, the underbidder’s bid, the reserve and a suggested step (offer at own bid, 24 hours at the reserve, or relist). Move to C once a few sales show where the gap should sit.
What your team sees in the admin
- An unpaid-lots queue: lot, winner, days overdue, underbidder and their bid, reserve, gap in percent, suggested step.
- One click sends the offer; a timer shows when it lapses; the next step comes up when it does.
- The difference owed by the non-payer, worked out per lot.
- Settings: acceptance time (24 hours or 3 days), the gap for C, and whether backup bids rank first (see Backup Bid).
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio builds the queue, the suggested step and the timers in the admin prototype. From you: who on your team handles the queue, 24 hours or 3 days, and the gap to use later.
How we measure it
| What it moves | How we measure it |
|---|---|
| Recovery | Unpaid lots resold; offers accepted; resale price against the winning bid |
| Speed | Days from default to resale |